Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System vs Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan
Side-by-side pension health comparison from DOL and public plan data
Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System and Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan are meaningfully apart on the LakeQuality pension-health rubric: Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System grades C while Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan grades A. Funding ratios: 48% vs 120%.
Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan comes out ahead on the composite rubric. For a participant in either plan, the spread is informative but not directly actionable — pension participation is not portable, so the relevant question is what each plan's funded-status trajectory means for that participant's benefit security.
Verdict
Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan has a stronger Pension Health Score of 100/100 (A) compared to Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System at 50/100 (C). Funding ratios differ by 71.5 percentage points (119.7% vs 48.2%). Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan covers 4,115 participants.
| Metric | Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System | Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan |
|---|---|---|
| Health Score Composite of funding ratio, trend, and PBGC risk | 50/100 (C) | 100/100 (A)* |
| Funding Ratio Assets as % of liabilities (100%+ is fully funded) | 48.2% | 119.7%* |
| Total Assets | $5.8B | $418.0M |
| Total Liabilities | $12.0B | $349.2M* |
| Unfunded Liability | $6.2B | $0* |
| Participants | 63,000 | 4,115 |
| 1-Year Investment Return | 4.8% | 6.2%* |
| Plan Type | public | corporate |
| PBGC Risk Level | high | low |
| Sponsor | City of Philadelphia | Alcoa Corporation |
Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan has a stronger Pension Health Score of 100/100 (A) compared to Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System at 50/100 (C). Funding ratios differ by 71.5 percentage points (119.7% vs 48.2%). Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan covers 4,115 participants.
Explore More
Related Comparisons
- Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System vs Pennsylvania Public School Employees Retirement System (PSERS)
- Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System vs Pennsylvania State Employees Retirement System (SERS)
- Philadelphia Municipal Retirement System vs US Steel Corporation Plan for Employee Pension Benefits
- Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan vs US Steel Corporation Plan for Employee Pension Benefits
- Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan vs Pennsylvania Public School Employees Retirement System (PSERS)
- Alcoa Corporation Retirement Plan vs Pennsylvania State Employees Retirement System (SERS)